Managing Eruptions, Reproducing Precarity: The Politics of Preparedness in Merapi Disaster Governance

Journal: Journal of Local Government Issues • • Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang • ISSN: 2620-8091

Abstract

Mount Merapi is often framed in disaster policy as a natural threat that requires an operational and coordinated response. This framing positions eruptions as extraordinary events (large-scale hazards), while the socio-economic vulnerability of communities on the slopes of Merapi is treated as a secondary context. This article examines disasters as a governance practice by analyzing how the state frames, calculates, classifies, and intervenes in risk over the 16 years following the major eruption of 2010. Rather than showing substantive transformation, this study finds a continuity of event-oriented, calculative, and short-term stabilization approaches. Based on in-depth interviews and focus group discussions with 34 survivors and institutional actors, the findings show that strengthened command structures, disaster information systems, hazard mapping, and standardized evacuation mechanisms reflect the rationalization of risk management rather than changes in the distribution of power. The state has become more effective in responding to eruptions as events, yet its intervention remains focused on impact control without addressing economic dependence on hazard-prone zones or inequalities in resource distribution. Using persistent precarity as an analytical tool, this article shows how this policy framing enables effective management of large-scale hazards while leaving the structural conditions of vulnerability largely unchanged.

Subjects & Keywords

How to Cite this Article

Suci Iriani Sinuraya, Anindya Dessi Wulansari, Sri Mulyani, et al. (2026). "Managing Eruptions, Reproducing Precarity: The Politics of Preparedness in Merapi Disaster Governance". Journal of Local Government Issues. https://doi.org/10.22219/logos.v9i2.44965