Measurement scales and statistics: A clash of paradigms.

Journal: Psychological Bulletin • • American Psychological Association • ISSN: 0033-2909

Abstract

The "permissible statistics " controversy stems from a clash of different theories or paradigms of measurement. Three theories are identified: the representational, the operational, and the classical. In each case the relation between measurement scales and statistical procedures is explored. The representational theory implies a relation between measurement scales and statistics, though not the one mentioned by Stevens or his followers. The operational and classical theories, for different rea-sons, imply no relation between measurement scales and statistics, contradicting Stevens's prescrip-tions. A resolution of this issue depends on a critical evaluation of these different theories. The recent exchange between Gaito (1980) and Townsend and Ashby (1984) shows that the controversy over measurement scales and statistics, begun by Stevens (1946), still persists. The two sides are as unrepentant as ever and show no sign of being able to appreciate the opposing point of view. Such a protracted controversy suggests that the disagreement lies much deeper than the arguments hitherto presented imply. If this is true then merely reciting these well-worn arguments will never resolve the issue. What is needed is a deeper analysis, one that probes to the disagreement's source. This source lies in the different con-ceptions of measurement. On one side of the debate, those fol-lowing the Stevens tradition have attempted to make explicit their theory of measurement. This is the representational the-ory. The opponents of this tradition have not been as prepared to lay their cards on the table, but one can discern within psy-chology at least two other, quite distinct measurement tradi-tions: the operational theory and the classical theory. The de-bate on this issue may be advanced by providing a clear state-ment of each of these theories and their implications regarding the use of statistical (or other numerical) procedures. That is my goal. I will not present arguments for or against these theo-ries at this stage.

Subjects & Keywords

How to Cite this Article

Joel Michell (1986). "Measurement scales and statistics: A clash of paradigms.". Psychological Bulletin. https://doi.org/10.1037//0033-2909.100.3.398