📖
An Analysis and Comparison of Two Short Writings: "Inaugural Address at the University of St. Andrew's" by J.S. Mill and "The University of Utopia" by R.M. Hutchins, Based on Five Criteria.
Poirier, Jeannine M.

An Analysis and Comparison of Two Short Writings: "Inaugural Address at the University of St. Andrew's" by J.S. Mill and "The University of Utopia" by R.M. Hutchins, Based on Five Criteria.

Author / Organization:
Education & Pedagogy Published 1977 Verification Pending

Overview & Synopsis

Focusing on the concept of education for work vs. education for living, the author presents a comparative analysis of two works on liberal education, each of which was originally delivered orally to university students: "The Inaugural Address at the University of St. Andrew" by John Stuart Mill and "The University of Utopia" by Robert Maynard Hutchins. Chapter 1 is an analysis of the two works. Chapter 2 expands further on the five criteria used as a basis of the comparison, giving the views of other author and educators on the criteria. The five criteria are (1) the concept of a university, (2) the concept of a university liberal arts education, (3) the curriculum of a liberal education, (4) the methods used in liberal arts education, and (5) the product of liberal university education. The third chapter compares the main ideas of the two authors, juxtaposing them for emphasis, with occasional references to other works. In a concluding section, focusing on the attempt to demonstrate that both Mill and Hutchins are strong exponents of liberal education, the author relates the thoughts of Mill and Hutchins to university education in modern society. (JT)

Indexed from repository: ERIC (Education Resources) (eric.ed.gov)
Loading document from verified source...
Keyboard Shortcuts: ← / → for pages • + / - for zoom • 0 to fit width Powered by Mozilla PDF.js v3.11

Document Information

Document Title An Analysis and Comparison of Two Short Writings: "Inaugural Address at the University of St. Andrew's" by J.S. Mill and "The University of Utopia" by R.M. Hutchins, Based on Five Criteria.
Author / Organization Poirier, Jeannine M.
Subject & Discipline College Curriculum, Comparative Analysis, Educational Methods
Categories Education & Pedagogy
Publication Year 1977
License / Rights Public Domain / Open Access Educational Resource
Resource Verification Listed PDF (Verification Pending)
Original Host Website ERIC (Education Resources) (eric.ed.gov)
File Format application/pdf (Portable Document Format)
Language EN
Catalog ID DOC-237239
Original Source Link Visit Source Page on eric.ed.gov »