📖
In Dialogue. A Response to Cathy Benedict, "Naming our Reality: Negotiating and Creating Meaning in the Margin"
Pio, Frederik

In Dialogue. A Response to Cathy Benedict, "Naming our Reality: Negotiating and Creating Meaning in the Margin"

Author / Organization:
Education & Pedagogy Published 2007 Verification Pending

Overview & Synopsis

In this paper we are offered a reflection on the historical and present marginalization of music education. As Cathy Benedict says, "What of this marginalization and what of its possibilities? I would like to suggest in this paper that this marginalized status partly reflects our own complicity as we have historically allowed others to speak for us." The field of music education in other words is suffering from a lack of independence. She goes on to say, "music educators have copied the perceived successes of the basic disciplines instead of striving for transformation." However, the radical transformation which is called for seems to lie neither in the integration of music education as part of general education nor in the isolation of music education for she adds, "if we continue to 'concern ourselves with possible future scenarios for music education as part of general education' and in a music education vacuum, then we will probably continue to construct what 'could be' in the guise of what has 'always been.' "

Indexed from repository: ERIC (Education Resources) (eric.ed.gov)

Document Information

Document Title In Dialogue. A Response to Cathy Benedict, "Naming our Reality: Negotiating and Creating Meaning in the Margin"
Author / Organization Pio, Frederik
Subject & Discipline Music Education, Curriculum Evaluation, Reader Response
Categories Education & Pedagogy
Publication Year 2007
License / Rights Public Domain / Open Access Educational Resource
Resource Verification Listed PDF (Verification Pending)
Original Host Website ERIC (Education Resources) (eric.ed.gov)
File Format application/pdf (Portable Document Format)
Language EN
Catalog ID DOC-247045
Original Source Link Visit Source Page on eric.ed.gov »