NAVIGATING INDETERMINACY IN EX-ANTE LCA: ASSESSING UNDISCOVERED MICROALGAL COMPOUNDS FOR HEALTH MANAGEMENT IN AQUACULTURE
Overview & Synopsis
In the face of ecological emergencies, various technological concepts are emerging to address the systemic issues confronting human societies and production systems. Although these concepts may appear promising at first look, it is crucial to anticipate the future environmental impacts associated with the market-scale deployment of these technologies. One of the emerging technological concepts is the use of new microalgal compounds to enhance health management in fish farms. This synergy presents an opportunity to create a market for high-value microalgal compounds, thereby alleviating the economic constraints faced by the microalgal sector and its diverse co-products, while simultaneously addressing the disease crisis prevalent in finfish farming. These compounds are currently at the center of bioprospecting efforts and thus remain undiscovered. They could be found in any microalgal strain and provide a vast range of potential bioactivities from therapeutic antiviral applications to prophylactic immunostimulation and growth enhancement. The final technological configuration emerging from this concept, which is still within the bioprospecting stage, therefore remains indeterminate. This PhD research aims to assess quantitatively the environmental impacts associated with this technological concept by performing an ex-ante Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of the use of undiscovered compounds for finfish farming across Europe. The primary objective is to provide decision-making support regarding the development of this concept. To do so, a stepwise approach is implemented to progressively acknowledge and quantitatively assess all the indeterminacies in the system and their associated levels of incertitude. The research begins by developing a novel parameterized LCA model to simulate the cultivation and production of any microalgal strain and compound in any location and season. Multiple forms of uncertainty are assessed regarding the European production of a yet undiscovered microalgal compound. This model is eventually combined with a new parameterized model for trout farming to assess the environmental impacts of producing fish using microalgal compounds that modulate the production characteristics of the fish farm. Uncertainty and global sensitivity analysis are performed thanks to stochastic propagations. The last part of this work acknowledges the deep uncertainty that lies upon the assessment and that hinders the definition of probabilities regarding the parameters’ values. As decision-making is still needed under such conditions, an algorithmic procedure is proposed and demonstrated to evaluate and approximate the probability of successful technological development. The results unravel the concept’s environmental signal which consists of probability distributions of impacts combined with a thorough understanding of how the different types of uncertainty interact and contribute to the impact uncertainty. The median global warming impact score across all potential European production mixes, strains, compounds, and photobioreactor setups amounted to 96 kg CO2-eq. per kilo of compound, which can be interpreted as a reasonable expectation of impact when the compound and its production locations remain unknown. The stepwise approach divided the work into standalone tasks that provided results and models for the microalgal and finfish farming sector. Thus, assessing the indeterminacies as stake led to performing an LCA of all microalgal products over Europe. This showed how the same microalgae productions environmentally perform once deployed over large geographic zones with distinct energy mixes, climates, and solar resources, instead of in single locations as previously assessed. In addition, the current environmental opportunity cost of mortality in the studied trout farm ranged from 3% to 5.5% across impact categories. Losses happening at the end of the production cycle were shown to greatly increase the overall life cycle impacts for trout production. Finally, this work presents theoretical and methodological advances for ex-ante LCA when applied to deeply uncertain technological concepts. In particular, this work highlighted the difference between risk and uncertainty as two forms of incertitude and proposed a procedure to make ex-ante LCA comply with this key distinction within post-normal science. This procedure informs on what decision-makers should be sure about to ensure a certain probability of successful technological development from an environmental point of view. Overall, this PhD study constitutes an ex-ante LCA of a very early-stage technological concept with a focus on decision-making in the face of deep uncertainty. The research places significant emphasis on recognizing the chaotic nature of technological development and deployment which are influenced by many factors that are difficult to control once the exploration of a concept is initiated. Examples of such uncontrollable factors include the outcomes of bioprospecting efforts and the integration of the concept into the market. The approach illustrates the use of ex-ante LCA to decide whether concepts should be further explored or if the limited available time and resources should be assigned to other concepts, especially from the perspective of performant technological planning under ecological emergency.
hal.science)
← / → for pages • + / - for zoom • 0 to fit width
Powered by Mozilla PDF.js v3.11
Document Information
| Document Title | NAVIGATING INDETERMINACY IN EX-ANTE LCA: ASSESSING UNDISCOVERED MICROALGAL COMPOUNDS FOR HEALTH MANAGEMENT IN AQUACULTURE |
|---|---|
| Author / Organization | Pierre Jouannais |
| Subject & Discipline | Multidisciplinary Academic Open Research |
| Categories | Science & Mathematics |
| Publication Year | 2023 |
| License / Rights | Open Access / Creative Commons |
| Resource Verification | Listed PDF (Verification Pending) |
| Original Host Website |
HAL Open Science
(hal.science)
|
| File Format | application/pdf (Portable Document Format) |
| Language | EN |
| Catalog ID | DOC-251002 |
| Original Source Link | Visit Source Page on hal.science » |